Showing posts with label Product Reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Product Reviews. Show all posts

Sunday, February 20, 2011

Book Review: The Working Cocker

Life has been a little crazy for me lately. I started working a new job that has me working long hours, and although I still find time to train the dogs, I don’t always find time to write about it. On top of that, I added a new addition to the family today. No, it’s not another ECS. This one is of the homo sapien variety. He came this morning and is doing great! Rocky has taken it upon himself to be the personal guardian of the baby (Bret), and at least for today he could usually be found somewhere close to the vicinity of Bret (as was the case for this picture).

In spite of all of the “hoopla” surrounding this weekend, I still found time to read The Working Cocker by P E Jones. When I arrived home from work Friday evening, I found it stuffed in my mailbox. I’d all but given up hope on seeing it because I’d been informed that it had been shipped at the end of December, but I had yet to see it. I figured that it must have got stuck in customs or lost in transit seeing that it had already been almost two months since shipping. It was certainly a pleasant surprise to find it in the box, and seemed to be perfect timing  having arrived at the start of a weekend!

Let me sum up my impression of the book very succinctly for you: I had a very busy weekend. I still managed to  finish reading the book early this afternoon. I liked the book a lot.

Now for the details. P E Jones does not know me from Adam, but I have been a “secret admirer” of his for the last couple of years. I have tried to find out anything I can about him over the internet, and have followed his success in field trails fairly closely. He has an extremely popular kennel name (Maesydderwen), and his dogs show up in a large number of ECS pedigrees. When I read the description of this book, I was excited because I thought that it would  give me a glimpse into Jones’ kennel. The book did not disappoint in the least.

Jones has a very personable style of writing. After reading the book, I almost felt that I knew him personally. He has a dry sense of humor that is prevalent throughout the book, and this makes for a very easy read. I had waited so long for this book that I wanted to make it last, so I found myself imposing mandatory breaks in order to draw it out a little longer! I would love to someday purchase a dog from Jones, and after reading his book, I feel that I wouldn’t hesitate to call him up on the phone as he seems like a very decent person.

Now, for the content more specifically. Here is what stood out to me:

1) I thoroughly enjoyed his material on the history of the breed. I have read a lot of material on the ECS breed, but a lot of what Jones wrote was completely new to me. It helped clarify some of the questions that I had, and was very informative. A number of times I found myself reading something to my wife that I thought interesting. She feigned interest, but really I think she was secretly making plans to wake me up in the middle of the night to go have a baby! Either way, I learned more about the ECS breed as a result of this book, and that’s saying a lot.

2) Generally, the training methods for Spaniels are fairly similar across the board. Most trainers follow the same general principals and then add their own little nuances. P E Jones is no different. Most of the training material in the book I had already learned from other sources. However, there were several things that were unique and that I will definitely implement into my training. One of these is a method that I have not seen anywhere else for improving a pup’s ability to track a runner. It makes sense, and will be a help for both hunting and competing. Throughout the training portion of the book Jones reminded me over and over again to not give an inch to my dogs. This served as an excellent reminder to me, and I know it had an impact on how I treated my dogs even today. He states at the start of the book that the training material in the book is more directed at the novice than at an experienced trainer, and I believe that is an accurate statement for the most part. The novice will find a lot of good material to implement in their training. On the other hand, I would think that even an advanced trainer would do well to at least read Jones’ material.

3) My undoubtedly favorite part of this book was the insight that it gave me into so many different Cockers, of whom previously I had only known as names on a page. Jones seems to know something about every single dog that I have ever tried to research on the internet. There were a number of dogs whose names I have researched, but was unable to acquire any information, that unbeknownst to me Jones had trialed, and provided a description of in the book. He also had pictures for a large number of these dogs, which made it even more interesting. Many of the dogs that he competed with in the past are the foundation stock for the dogs that we own today, and I at least found it fascinating to read about these dogs that contributed to the dogs that are currently curled up at my feet!

So, who would I recommend this book to? Anyone who is truly an enthusiast of English Cockers will benefit from this book. I have this extremely strong addiction for the breed that creates a strong appetite to learn everything I can about these great dogs. This appetite is not easily satiated, but Jones’ book did more than any material that I have ever read to at least curb the hunger pains. I found it extremely interesting to learn about the breed from someone “on that side of the pond”, and it was clear that he knows more about the history and the founding dogs of the breed than most, if not all writers here in the US. I feel strongly that if you are a fan of the ECS breed, then you owe it to yourself to purchase this book. It will provide you with an excellent read, and will make an excellent resource to have in your collection. Not only for training material, but also to reference a particular dog that might be in a pedigree you’re interested in. 

I can’t say enough good things about this book, and would heartily recommend it to my fellow Cocker enthusiasts.

Thursday, December 16, 2010

Urban Gundogs: Training Flushing Dogs for Home & Field

Urban Gun Dogs: Training Flushing Dogs For Home And FieldImmediately prior to my purchase of Macy I stumbled across this book written by Tony Roettger and Ben Schleider III. What intrigued me most about this book was that it was written by guys who train Cockers, and it was written for guys living in town (like me). In my juvenile dog training state, I figured that reading a book written by Cocker guys would make sense. It turned out to be a very beneficial purchase for my particular situation. In the introduction chapter, Ben gives the objective for the book quite well when he says, “this book is written primarily for the novice gun dog owner who is a working stiff.”

The book is written in a very readable style, and follows a logical progression the entire way through. It has has lots of high quality pictures in it of different dogs; the pictures obviously don’t help with the training, but it makes the book more entertaining. I especially appreciated the portions of the book that discuss preparing for competitions, and avoiding pitfalls. It was also beneficial that this was written urban dog owners. The authors don’t assume that you have lots of land at your disposal, so they mostly cover training methods that you can use with limited space.

While there is no earth-shattering material in the book, it is a good solid read. In fact, I picked it up last night to skim through it again (I’ve already read it a couple of times) and picked up on a few things that I’d like to start incorporating into my training. I would also recommend that anyone who is looking to get their first Cocker buy this book prior to getting their puppy. It has good information about choosing the right breed, finding quality puppies, etc. I am sure there are books out there that are more comprehensive, or that are stronger in particular areas, but overall I don’t think you can go wrong with this book if you are new to gundog training, or if you’ve been training for a while but want some new ideas.

Monday, December 6, 2010

Hawcroft Training DVD

Although I have owned gun dogs for a long time and spent a considerable amount of time training and hunting gun dogs, I still consider myself to be somewhat of a novice in training them. I was able to get Macy to the point where I felt that she was a decent pheasant hunting dog, but she certainly wasn’t a hunting dog that I would want to show off, and I didn’t know how to get her past that point. I also wanted to make sure I was giving Rocky every opportunity to progress as he should. So, I scoured the internet for free videos that could potentially help me with my dilemma. However, I discovered that even finding a video that has a Cocker in it can be challenging, let alone one with a well trained Cocker! I spent a lot of time reading books and forums (see links in the right hand margin), but felt that I still needed to actually SEE training in progress, not just read about.
During one of my regular perusing sessions on the internet, I came across the Hawcroft Gundogs  website. Simon Tyers is the owner of this kennel, and he took the time to put together a rather lengthy training series (5+ hrs) that is directed specifically at Cockers. Simon has a rather impressive resume, as you will find from reading his website, and I was intrigued by the DVDs that he is offering on his website. I would have bought them immediately, but they are somewhat cost inhibitive. However, as I considered the amount of time and money that I had already put into my dogs, and also considered where I wanted to eventually end up with my dogs (finely-tuned hunting machines!), I decided to spring for the DVDs. Simon offers the DVDs for sale on his website, but I have been told that he can be difficult to contact because he has a busy field trailing schedule. The DVDs are also available from Paul French Video International, which is where I purchased mine from. The cost is £99.95, which comes out to roughly $157, plus shipping. My DVDs were in my hands about 4 days after I ordered them, so shipping speed was relatively fast.
I purchased all three of the DVDs, although they can be purchased separately if you only feel you need help at a specific point in your training. For further explanation of what is covered in each of the three DVDs, click on the Paul French link above. It gives specific details as to what Simon covers in each one.
I’ll start off by covering what I felt were the positives about these DVDs, and then I will move to the negatives. First, I found the DVDs to be interesting the entire way through. I watched all five hours in one day, and have since watched them at least once more. Simon uses different Cockers all the way through the DVDs, and I found it interesting to see his interactions with each Cocker, and also to see the different personalities of each dog. I thought this was much more helpful than using one Cocker throughout. I know that my two Cockers have different personalities from each other, and to try to train both of them the same way would be disastrous, so watching Simon handle each Cocker was beneficial to me.
Second, I found the DVDs to be relatively comprehensive. Five hours is a fair amount of time, and he has it fairly well packed with training. Simon covers everything from tiny puppies all the way through an almost finished dog. While the first DVD was not very relevant to my situation, I still watched it and found it to be helpful. I know that the next time I go to choose a puppy (hopefully in the not-so-distant future), I will refer back to this DVD to refresh my memory. The second and third DVDs cover everything that you would need to turn a Cocker into a hunting machine.
Third, I appreciated Simon’s training methods. He does all of his training without the use of e-collars. He also is very gentle with his dogs, and keeps everything very calm in his training. He will occasionally use a harsh word with his dogs, or scruff a neck, but it is very clear from the DVDs that he is in no way harming his dogs. I was very impressed at how relaxed and patient he is throughout the entire training process. He does not always use well trained dogs to demonstrate his training, and in some cases the videos capture his first sessions with different Cockers. Obviously,  these Cockers did not immediately respond to his methods, so it was beneficial to watch his patience and repetition with these Cockers.
The negatives were very scare from these DVDs, but still should be mentioned. First, when the last DVD ended, I was left wishing there was more to watch. It would have been useful to watch him actually running a Cocker in a field trail, or least be informed what other steps were necessary to get a Cocker to the field trail level. The series ends with a Cocker that would be a phenomenal hunter, but that is not quite ready for a field trail. I suppose that it is also a positive for these DVDs that after watching five hours of them I still wanted more!
Second, I would have liked a more information about how much time Simon spends training each Cocker, and the normal amount of time that it takes him to accomplish each step of the training. I expect that he left this information at so as to not create false expectations for owners with their Cockers, but at the same time a general idea would have been helpful. Sometimes I feel that I spend too much time training a particular command and maybe “over-train” the command. Knowing when Simon feels it is time to move on, and when it is time to go back to that command would have been helpful.
Third, Simon is training his dogs specifically for European field trails. Because of this, a portion of the series is spent on training for rabbits. While I do not discourage my dogs from flushing rabbits, I also wouldn’t care if they didn’t. Some of you might hate the thought of your Cocker sniffing a rabbit, so that part of the DVDs might be particularly frustrating to you. However, if you have a true Field Bred English Cocker Spaniel, keep in mind that it’s not-so-distant ancestors were going after rabbits, so it might be a hard animal to break your Cocker of showing interest in!
Before concluding, let me mention in a generic way some of the things that I learned from these DVDs. First, I learned a more calm and patient method of training. I wouldn’t have considered myself to be a spastic trainer prior to watching these DVDs, but I know that I learned to use a quieter voice and to be more patient in the repetition of training commands. Second, I increased my confidence in administering correction to my Cockers. I now have a much better grasp on how much correction to use, and when to use it. Third, I learned a lot about creating an insatiable desire to retrieve. In this day and age of force-fetching, it was very encouraging to see a trainer that cultivates a natural desire to retrieve, rather than using the alternative of force-fetching. Fourth, I learned a lot about how to get my Cockers to do things such as making blind retrieves, memory retrieves, quartering, and steadying to flush and shot.
To wrap this up, I found these DVDs to be extremely helpful and well worth the cost for me. Now, if your money is really tight, you could probably survive without having them. However, if you lack confidence in your training, or just want to take it to the next level, these DVDs could be very beneficial for you. Many of the things that I watched on these DVDs I had already read about elsewhere, but it was extremely helpful for me to actually WATCH it take place, rather than just reading about it. I plan on keeping my DVDs and referencing back to them from time to time, so I can without hesitation recommend them to you.

Friday, December 3, 2010

Mendota Skid Plate

I suppose that right now I should be relishing the amount of post topics that I have at my disposal. I have hunting stories, gear, dog biographies, etc. that I would like to write about…but I can only write about one at a time! I imagine that further down the road I will have to be creative in order to come up with relevant posts, but for now that’s not a problem
After hunting quail in the Texas Panhandle (I’ll write about the trip some other time), I decided that finding a quality chest protector for my dogs was in order. There are obviously certain types of terrain that don’t necessitate a chest protector, but the amount of cacti and barbed wire in the panhandle were hard on Macy. I was pulling thorns out of her chest for at least ten days after the hunt. I know there are also places in the midwest that have an abundance of barbed wire, so I will probably use the chest protectors when I got up there in a month.
When looking for a chest protector for my dogs, I had three criteria. First, it had to fit them. This is not always an easy task with Cockers. Second, it had to be “skimpy” enough that they wouldn’t overheat while working in the Texas heat. Third, it had to be durable enough to withstand multiple hunting trips. I found what I was looking for in the Mendota Skid Plate. It comes in a size small, which seems to be just small enough to fit my cockers, and it has straps that go across the back, rather than fabric, so it doesn’t overheat the dogs. It is also extremely durable. The straps are very heavy duty, and the Cordura fabric is very tough. The only grip that I have is that the straps that go around the neck could maybe bit a little shorter. They are adjustable, but even with the adjusted all the way down, it seems like the fabric is maybe not quite as tight across the chest as I would like. I am toying with the idea of cutting the straps and sewing them shorter, but my wife has informed me that her sewing machine will not handle sewing through the straps. So, I’m either going to have to do it by hand, or just tolerate having the fabric a little loose on the chest. I’m leaning toward the latter :) Rocky seems to fill it out across the chest better than Macy anyway, so I would think that any Cocker above 30lbs would probably fit this vest well.
At the time of this post, the best place I found to buy the Skid Plate was off of Gander Mountain’s website. They have it cheaper than anywhere else I could find ($24.99), and they offered free shipping on it.
You’ll find pictures of my Cockers sporting the vests in my two previous posts.
Here is the factory picture:
  Skid plate
On a side note, I am currently operating the photo department of this blog with my wife’s camera, which is only occasionally available for my use (she’s pretty protective of it), and it is not the highest quality camera. I would love to be able to justify purchasing a nicer camera, but I first I need to know that this blog will be appreciated by a fair number of people. So, hang in there, better pictures should be on the way! For now, hopefully my words will captivate you:) Haha, ya right.